InsideGov
Congress · Laws

Pension Funding Equity Act of 2004

Public Law 108-218 · H.R. 3108 · 108th Congress · began in the House

Signed by George W. Bush (R) on Apr 10, 2004 · Labor and Employment

Sponsor: Rep. John Boehner (R-OH-8)

Cosponsors (10): Rep. Bill Thomas,

Passage votesYeaNay

  • HouseRecorded vote: 336 yea, 69 nay336–69
  • SenateRecorded vote: 78 yea, 19 nay78–19
Data notes

The final version of the law, as each chamber passed it. A chamber that passed it by voice vote or unanimous consent has no count. “Method not stated” means the record does not say how the chamber voted. Where the record has a member-by-member vote, the “Who voted for it” section shows who voted yea.

Report a correction

Summary

The Congressional Research Service’s plain-language summary of what the law does.

Pension Funding Equity Act of 2004 - Title I: Pension Funding - (Sec. 101) Amends the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) and the Internal Revenue Code (Code) to temporarily replace (for plan years 2004 and 2005) the 30-year Treasury rate with a rate based on long-term corporate bonds for certain pension plan funding requirements.

Directs the Secretary of the Treasury to: (1) determine the permissible range of such rate on the basis of two or more indices that are selected periodically from the the top three quality levels available; and (2) make such range public, as well as indices and methodology used to determine such weighted average rate.

(Sec. 102) Allows applicable employers to elect to make alternative deficit reduction contributions under ERISA and the Code. Defines applicable employers as: (1) commercial passenger airlines; (2) those primarily engaged in production or manufacture of steel mill products or the processing of iron ore pellets; or (3) a specified type of organization that established its plan on June 30, 1955. Allows such an employer, if the defined benefit plan met certain requirements in 2000, to elect an alternative type of increase for up to two plan years that begin after December 27, 2003, and before December 28, 2005. Restricts benefit increases during such applicable plan year unless specified conditions are met. Requires employers who elect such an alternative deficit reduction contribution to notify participants, beneficiaries, and the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC).

(Sec. 103) Establishes ERISA requirements for multiemployer defined benefit plan funding notices. Requires plan administrators to send such notices to participants, beneficiaries, labor organizations, and employers for each plan year, within a specified time, form, and manner. Requires such notices to include information on: (1) the plan's funded current liability percentage; (2) the value of the plan's assets, the amount of benefit payments, and the ratio of the assets to the payments for the plan year; (3) rules governing insolvent multiemployer plans, including limitations on benefit payments, potential benefit reductions and suspensions, and potential effects on the plan; and (4) plan benefits eligible to be guaranteed by the PBGC, and circumstances limiting such guarantee. Directs the Secretary of Labor to issue regulations, including a model notice.

(Sec. 104) Permits, under ERISA and the Code, certain eligible multiemployer plan sponsors to elect to defer a charge for a portion of a net experience loss. Allows, with respect to such loss for the first plan year beginning after December 31, 2001, such deferral of up to 80 percent of the amount otherwise required to be charged for any plan year beginning after June 30, 2003, and before July 1, 2005, to any plan year selected by the plan from either of the two immediately succeeding plan years. Prohibits any plan amendments which increase plan liabilities by increasing benefits from taking effect during such deferral period, unless specified conditions are met.

Makes a multiemployer plan eligible to elect such deferral if: (1) it had a net investment loss (determined on the basis of actual loss) for the first plan year beginning after December 31, 2001, of at least ten percent of the average fair market value of its assets during the plan year; and (2) its enrolled actuary certifies, on the basis of the actuarial assumptions used for the last plan year ending before the enactment date of this Act, that it is projected to have an accumulated funding deficiency for any plan year beginning between June 30, 2003, and July 1, 2006. Makes a plan ineligible if: (1) any of its required employer contributors failed to timely pay an excise tax imposed on the plan, for any taxable year beginning during the preceding ten-year period; (2) the average contribution required to be made by all employers to it does not exceed ten cents per hour, or no employer is required to make contributions to it, for any plan year beginning after June 30, 1993; or (3) it was granted a specified waiver or an amortization period extension, for any plan year beginning after June 30, 1993.

Title II: Other Provisions - (Sec. 201) Provides for a special two-year extension, for plan years beginning in 2004 and 2005, of a transition rule, under the Retirement Protection Act of 1994, as amended by the Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997, with respect to certain pension funding requirements under ERISA and the Code. Allows a certain defined benefit plan, in 2004 and 2005, to use a special mortality table in calculating funding liability and to be exempt from a deficit reduction contribution and variable premiums to the PBGC.

(Sec. 202) Sets forth a special ERISA procedure for certain disputes between a multiemployer plan sponsor and an employer involving pension plan withdrawal liability. Shifts, from the employer to the plan sponsor, the burden of proof that the employer created a subsidiary to avoid the employer's liability for plan termination, if: (1) the transaction occurred before January 1, 1999, and at least five years before the date of complete or partial withdrawal; and (2) the employer receives a certain notification under ERISA after October 31, 2003.

(Sec. 203) Expresses the sense of Congress that it must ensure the financial health of the defined benefit pension system by working to implement promptly: (1) a permanent replacement for the pension discount rate used for defined benefit pension plan calculations; and (2) comprehensive funding reforms, for all defined benefit pension plans, aimed at achieving accurate and sound pension funding

(Sec. 204) Extends, until December 31, 2013, Code and ERISA provisions permitting the transfer of excess pension assets to retiree health accounts.

(Sec. 205) Repeals a Code provision requiring reduction of the policyholder dividend deductions of mutual life insurance companies.

(Sec. 206) Revises the definition of small property and casualty insurance companies (insurance companies other than life insurance companies) exempt from income taxes to specify: (1) a company whose gross receipts for the taxable year do not exceed $600,000, and over half such gross receipts consist of premiums (currently, whose net written premiums (or, if greater, direct written premiums) for the taxable year do not exceed $350,000); or (2) a mutual insurance company (with certain exceptions) whose gross receipts of which for the taxable year do not exceed $150,000, and more than 35 percent of such gross receipts consist of premiums.

(Sec. 207) Declares that graduate medical resident matching programs do not violate Federal or State antitrust laws.

Who voted for it

Every House member of the 108th Congress on the ideology compass. Highlighted: the 336 who voted yea on final passage. Faded: everyone else, including those who voted nay, did not vote, or had not yet taken office.

336 yea69 nay29 present or did not vote

Dimension 2
Economic left–right
More liberalMore conservative

Democrats who voted yea(137)

  • Rep. John ConyersD-MI-14
  • Rep. Jim McDermottD-WA-7
  • Rep. Jan SchakowskyD-IL-9
  • Rep. James OberstarD-MN-8
  • Rep. Jesse JacksonD-IL-2
  • Rep. Maurice HincheyD-NY-22
  • Rep. Tammy BaldwinD-WI-2
  • Rep. Jim McGovernD-MA-3
  • Rep. Stephanie JonesD-OH-11
  • Rep. Ed TownsD-NY-10
  • Rep. Wm. ClayD-MO-1
  • Rep. Mike HondaD-CA-15
  • Rep. Peter DeFazioD-OR-4
  • Rep. Sam FarrD-CA-17
  • Rep. Bill DelahuntD-MA-10
  • Rep. Jerrold NadlerD-NY-8
  • Rep. Danny DavisD-IL-7
  • Rep. Louise SlaughterD-NY-28
  • Rep. Julia CarsonD-IN-7
  • Rep. Carolyn KilpatrickD-MI-13
  • Rep. Lloyd DoggettD-TX-10
  • Rep. Sheila Jackson LeeD-TX-18
  • Rep. Charlie RangelD-NY-15
  • Rep. Nancy PelosiD-CA-8
  • Rep. Bobby RushD-IL-1
  • Rep. Bobby ScottD-VA-3
  • Rep. Martin SaboD-MN-5
  • Rep. Lane EvansD-IL-17
  • Rep. Eddie JohnsonD-TX-30
  • Rep. Rosa DeLauroD-CT-3
  • Rep. José SerranoD-NY-16
  • Rep. Ed PastorD-AZ-4
  • Rep. Elijah CummingsD-MD-7
  • Rep. Diana DeGetteD-CO-1
  • Rep. Jerry KleczkaD-WI-4
  • Rep. Juanita Millender-McDonaldD-CA-37
  • Rep. John LarsonD-CT-1
  • Rep. Earl BlumenauerD-OR-3
  • Rep. Lois CappsD-CA-23
  • Rep. Richard NealD-MA-2
  • Rep. Dave ObeyD-WI-7
  • Rep. Tom AllenD-ME-1
  • Rep. Betty McCollumD-MN-4
  • Rep. Mark UdallD-CO-2
  • Rep. Gary AckermanD-NY-5
  • Rep. Chris Van HollenD-MD-8
  • Rep. Anthony WeinerD-NY-9
  • Rep. Brad ShermanD-CA-27
  • Rep. Carolyn MaloneyD-NY-14
  • Rep. Brian BairdD-WA-3
  • Rep. John DingellD-MI-15
  • Rep. Tom LantosD-CA-12
  • Rep. Robert MatsuiD-CA-5
  • Rep. Bart StupakD-MI-1
  • Rep. Rahm EmanuelD-IL-5
  • Rep. William JeffersonD-LA-2
  • Rep. Kendrick MeekD-FL-17
  • Rep. Jay InsleeD-WA-1
  • Rep. Mike ThompsonD-CA-1
  • Rep. Rick LarsenD-WA-2
  • Rep. Ciro RodriguezD-TX-28
  • Rep. Gregory MeeksD-NY-6
  • Rep. Dale KildeeD-MI-5
  • Rep. Steny HoyerD-MD-5
  • Rep. Sander LevinD-MI-12
  • Rep. Timothy BishopD-NY-1
  • Rep. Joe CrowleyD-NY-7
  • Rep. Harold FordD-TN-9
  • Rep. Joseph HoeffelD-PA-13
  • Rep. Adam SchiffD-CA-29
  • Rep. Chris BellD-TX-25
  • Rep. Nita LoweyD-NY-18
  • Rep. Michael DoyleD-PA-14
  • Rep. Peter DeutschD-FL-20
  • Rep. Nick RahallD-WV-3
  • Rep. Nick LampsonD-TX-9
  • Rep. Shelley BerkleyD-NV-1
  • Rep. Ellen TauscherD-CA-10
  • Rep. David WuD-OR-1
  • Rep. Marion BerryD-AR-1
  • Rep. Susan DavisD-CA-53
  • Rep. Albert WynnD-MD-4
  • Rep. Benjamin CardinD-MD-3
  • Rep. Michael MichaudD-ME-2
  • Rep. Paul KanjorskiD-PA-11
  • Rep. Martin FrostD-TX-24
  • Rep. David PriceD-NC-4
  • Rep. Norm DicksD-WA-6
  • Rep. Artur DavisD-AL-7
  • Rep. Bob EtheridgeD-NC-2
  • Rep. Jane HarmanD-CA-36
  • Rep. Rubén HinojosaD-TX-15
  • Rep. John SprattD-SC-5
  • Rep. Steve IsraelD-NY-2
  • Rep. Charlie GonzalezD-TX-20
  • Rep. Jim MoranD-VA-8
  • Rep. Darlene HooleyD-OR-5
  • Rep. Jim DavisD-FL-11
  • Rep. Alan MollohanD-WV-1
  • Rep. A. Dutch RuppersbergerD-MD-2
  • Rep. Ron KindD-WI-3
  • Rep. Mike RossD-AR-4
  • Rep. Max SandlinD-TX-1
  • Rep. Baron HillD-IN-9
  • Rep. Jim CooperD-TN-5
  • Rep. Leonard BoswellD-IA-3
  • Rep. Dennis MooreD-KS-3
  • Rep. Sanford BishopD-GA-2
  • Rep. Vic SnyderD-AR-2
  • Rep. Solomon OrtizD-TX-27
  • Rep. Adam SmithD-WA-9
  • Rep. Dennis CardozaD-CA-18
  • Rep. Mike McIntyreD-NC-7
  • Rep. Ed CaseD-HI-2
  • Rep. Earl PomeroyD-ND
  • Rep. Rick BoucherD-VA-9
  • Rep. Ben ChandlerD-KY-6
  • Rep. David ScottD-GA-13
  • Rep. Tim HoldenD-PA-17
  • Rep. Ike SkeltonD-MO-4
  • Rep. Jim TurnerD-TX-2
  • Rep. John MurthaD-PA-12
  • Rep. William LipinskiD-IL-3
  • Rep. Chet EdwardsD-TX-11
  • Rep. Bart GordonD-TN-6
  • Rep. Cal DooleyD-CA-20
  • Rep. Brad CarsonD-OK-2
  • Rep. Lincoln DavisD-TN-4
  • Rep. Jim MarshallD-GA-3
  • Rep. Allen BoydD-FL-2
  • Rep. Jim MathesonD-UT-2
  • Rep. Chris JohnD-LA-7
  • Rep. Collin PetersonD-MN-7
  • Rep. Charlie StenholmD-TX-17
  • Rep. Ken LucasD-KY-4
  • Rep. Rodney AlexanderD-LA-5
  • Rep. Bud CramerD-AL-5

Republicans who voted yea(199)

  • Rep. Jim LeachR-IA-2
  • Rep. Michael CastleR-DE
  • Rep. Christopher ShaysR-CT-4
  • Rep. Timothy JohnsonR-IL-15
  • Rep. Doug BereuterR-NE-1
  • Rep. Rob SimmonsR-CT-2
  • Rep. Sherry BoehlertR-NY-24
  • Rep. Chris SmithR-NJ-4
  • Rep. Heather WilsonR-NM-1
  • Rep. John McHughR-NY-23
  • Rep. Fred UptonR-MI-6
  • Rep. Steven LaTouretteR-OH-14
  • Rep. Jack QuinnR-NY-27
  • Rep. Sue KellyR-NY-19
  • Rep. Shelley CapitoR-WV-2
  • Rep. Curt WeldonR-PA-7
  • Rep. Pete KingR-NY-3
  • Rep. Jon PorterR-NV-3
  • Rep. Jim GerlachR-PA-6
  • Rep. Vernon EhlersR-MI-3
  • Rep. Jo Ann EmersonR-MO-8
  • Rep. Mike FergusonR-NJ-7
  • Rep. Nancy JohnsonR-CT-5
  • Rep. Frank WolfR-VA-10
  • Rep. Phil EnglishR-PA-3
  • Rep. Tom LathamR-IA-4
  • Rep. Rodney FrelinghuysenR-NJ-11
  • Rep. Rick RenziR-AZ-1
  • Rep. Todd PlattsR-PA-19
  • Rep. Bob NeyR-OH-18
  • Rep. George NethercuttR-WA-5
  • Rep. Mary Bono MackR-CA-45
  • Rep. Mark KirkR-IL-10
  • Rep. Clay ShawR-FL-22
  • Rep. Tom DavisR-VA-11
  • Rep. Greg WaldenR-OR-2
  • Rep. Ralph RegulaR-OH-16
  • Rep. Dave HobsonR-OH-7
  • Rep. Tom OsborneR-NE-3
  • Rep. Jim GreenwoodR-PA-8
  • Rep. Ralph HallD-TX-4
  • Rep. Tim MurphyR-PA-18
  • Rep. Candice MillerR-MI-10
  • Rep. Ken CalvertR-CA-44
  • Rep. Wayne GilchrestR-MD-1
  • Rep. Paul GillmorR-OH-5
  • Rep. Jeb BradleyR-NH-1
  • Rep. John PetersonR-PA-5
  • Rep. Mark FoleyR-FL-16
  • Rep. Chip PickeringR-MS-3
  • Rep. Thad McCotterR-MI-11
  • Rep. Deborah PryceR-OH-15
  • Rep. Anne NorthupR-KY-3
  • Rep. Michael TurnerR-OH-3
  • Rep. Jerry LewisR-CA-41
  • Rep. Don SherwoodR-PA-10
  • Rep. Jerry WellerR-IL-11
  • Rep. Judy BiggertR-IL-13
  • Rep. W. Bill YoungR-FL-10
  • Rep. Jim KolbeR-AZ-8
  • Rep. Mike RogersR-AL-3
  • Rep. Don YoungR-AK
  • Rep. Henry HydeR-IL-6
  • Rep. Joe KnollenbergR-MI-9
  • Rep. Mike SimpsonR-ID-2
  • Rep. Ander CrenshawR-FL-4
  • Rep. Dave CampR-MI-4
  • Rep. Hal RogersR-KY-5
  • Rep. Frank LucasR-OK-3
  • Rep. Ginny Brown-WaiteR-FL-5
  • Rep. Kay GrangerR-TX-12
  • Rep. Henry BrownR-SC-1
  • Rep. Jim NussleR-IA-1
  • Rep. Max BurnsR-GA-12
  • Rep. Porter GossR-FL-14
  • Rep. Darrell IssaR-CA-49
  • Rep. Duke CunninghamR-CA-50
  • Rep. Roger WickerR-MS-1
  • Rep. Bill ThomasR-CA-22
  • Rep. Robert AderholtR-AL-4
  • Rep. Henry BonillaR-TX-23
  • Rep. Buck McKeonR-CA-25
  • Rep. David DreierR-CA-26
  • Rep. Jerry MoranR-KS-1
  • Rep. Zach WampR-TN-3
  • Rep. Devin NunesR-CA-21
  • Rep. Lamar SmithR-TX-21
  • Rep. Jennifer DunnR-WA-8
  • Rep. Mike RogersR-MI-8
  • Rep. John BoozmanR-AR-3
  • Rep. John MicaR-FL-7
  • Rep. Michael OxleyR-OH-4
  • Rep. Bill ShusterR-PA-9
  • Rep. Tom ColeR-OK-4
  • Rep. Thomas ReynoldsR-NY-26
  • Rep. Spencer BachusR-AL-6
  • Rep. Charlie BassR-NH-2
  • Rep. Steve PearceR-NM-2
  • Rep. Cass BallengerR-NC-10
  • Rep. Bill JenkinsR-TN-1
  • Rep. Jo BonnerR-AL-1
  • Rep. Ron LewisR-KY-2
  • Rep. Doc HastingsR-WA-4
  • Rep. Robin HayesR-NC-8
  • Rep. Adam PutnamR-FL-12
  • Rep. Pat TiberiR-OH-12
  • Rep. Jim McCreryR-LA-4
  • Rep. Mark SouderR-IN-3
  • Rep. Duncan HunterR-CA-52
  • Rep. Richard PomboR-CA-11
  • Rep. Jo Ann DavisR-VA-1
  • Rep. Richard BakerR-LA-6
  • Rep. Steve BuyerR-IN-4
  • Rep. Katherine HarrisR-FL-13
  • Rep. Virgil GoodeR-VA-5
  • Rep. Randy ForbesR-VA-4
  • Rep. Charles TaylorR-NC-11
  • Rep. Todd TiahrtR-KS-4
  • Rep. Dave WeldonR-FL-15
  • Rep. John DoolittleR-CA-4
  • Rep. John BoehnerR-OH-8
  • Rep. George RadanovichR-CA-19
  • Rep. Ernest IstookR-OK-5
  • Rep. Melissa HartR-PA-4
  • Rep. Roy BluntR-MO-7
  • Rep. Walter JonesR-NC-3
  • Rep. John ShimkusR-IL-19
  • Rep. Dan BurtonR-IN-5
  • Rep. Bob GoodlatteR-VA-6
  • Rep. Jim RamstadR-MN-3
  • Rep. Ed SchrockR-VA-2
  • Rep. Sam GravesR-MO-6
  • Rep. John KlineR-MN-2
  • Rep. Phil GingreyR-GA-11
  • Rep. Tom DeLayR-TX-22
  • Rep. Mark GreenR-WI-8
  • Rep. Ric KellerR-FL-8
  • Rep. Terry EverettR-AL-2
  • Rep. Jim RyunR-KS-2
  • Rep. Eric CantorR-VA-7
  • Rep. Mario Diaz-BalartR-FL-25
  • Rep. John CarterR-TX-31
  • Rep. John SullivanR-OK-1
  • Rep. Lee TerryR-NE-2
  • Rep. Scott McInnisR-CO-3
  • Rep. Jim GibbonsR-NV-2
  • Rep. Donald ManzulloR-IL-16
  • Rep. Bob BeauprezR-CO-7
  • Rep. Jack KingstonR-GA-1
  • Rep. Joe BartonR-TX-6
  • Rep. Pete HoekstraR-MI-2
  • Rep. Johnny IsaksonR-GA-6
  • Rep. J.D. HayworthR-AZ-5
  • Rep. Mark KennedyR-MN-6
  • Rep. Chris ChocolaR-IN-2
  • Rep. Tom PetriR-WI-6
  • Rep. John LinderR-GA-7
  • Rep. Gary MillerR-CA-42
  • Rep. Mac ThornberryR-TX-13
  • Rep. Randy NeugebauerR-TX-19
  • Rep. Michael BurgessR-TX-26
  • Rep. Joe WilsonR-SC-2
  • Rep. Gil GutknechtR-MN-1
  • Rep. Kevin BradyR-TX-8
  • Rep. Joseph PittsR-PA-16
  • Rep. Howard CobleR-NC-6
  • Rep. Steve ChabotR-OH-1
  • Rep. Christopher CoxR-CA-48
  • Rep. Paul RyanR-WI-1
  • Rep. Barbara CubinR-WY
  • Rep. Marsha BlackburnR-TN-7
  • Rep. Wally HergerR-CA-2
  • Rep. Pete SessionsR-TX-32
  • Rep. Chris CannonR-UT-3
  • Rep. Phil CraneR-IL-8
  • Rep. Mac CollinsR-GA-8
  • Rep. Sam JohnsonR-TX-3
  • Rep. John HostettlerR-IN-8
  • Rep. Steve KingR-IA-5
  • Rep. Marilyn MusgraveR-CO-4
  • Rep. Todd AkinR-MO-2
  • Rep. J. Gresham BarrettR-SC-3
  • Rep. Jimmy DuncanR-TN-2
  • Rep. Nick SmithR-MI-7
  • Rep. Scott GarrettR-NJ-5
  • Rep. Cliff StearnsR-FL-6
  • Rep. Mike PenceR-IN-6
  • Rep. Tom FeeneyR-FL-24
  • Rep. Joel HefleyR-CO-5
  • Rep. Dana RohrabacherR-CA-46
  • Rep. Jeb HensarlingR-TX-5
  • Rep. Tom TancredoR-CO-6
  • Rep. Ed RoyceR-CA-40
  • Rep. Roscoe BartlettR-MD-6
  • Rep. James SensenbrennerR-WI-5
  • Rep. Jeff MillerR-FL-1
  • Rep. Pat ToomeyR-PA-15
  • Rep. John ShadeggR-AZ-3
  • Rep. Trent FranksR-AZ-2
Data notes

The House’s recorded vote on the final version of the law (roll call 791 in Voteview), matched to the vote the record cites and checked against its totals. Positions are each member’s DW-NOMINATE score for that Congress, as on the Ideology page; left to right is more liberal to more conservative. Paired and announced yea votes count as yea. Lists follow the compass, most liberal first. A name links to a profile only for members of the current Congress. A law passed by voice vote or unanimous consent has no member list, and neither does a vote Voteview has not yet recorded.

Report a correction

Committees

The committees the bill was sent to, and what each did with it.

Data notes

A committee links to its page only where it exists in the current Congress; older and renamed committees are named without a link.

Report a correction

Related bills

The record lists no related bills.

Data notes

Related bills are identified by the Congressional Research Service, the House and the Senate: companion and identical bills, bills with similar text, bills that were folded into this law, and rules that brought it to the floor. A bill that is itself a public law in this site’s data links here; the others link to Congress.gov.

Report a correction

Timeline

From introduction to signing, newest first: the committees, the floor and the president. 48 actions.

  1. Apr 10, 2004Became lawBecame law · Became Public Law No: 108-218.
  2. Became lawBecame law · Signed by President.
  3. Apr 9, 2004FloorFloor · Presented to President.
  4. Apr 8, 2004Resolving differencesResolving differences · Senate agreed to conference report by Yea-Nay Vote. 78 - 19. Record Vote Number: 68.Senate roll call 68
  5. Resolving differencesResolving differences · Conference report agreed to in Senate: Senate agreed to conference report by Yea-Nay Vote. 78 - 19. Record Vote Number: 68.Senate roll call 68
  6. Resolving differencesResolving differences · Conference report considered in Senate.
  7. FloorFloor · Message on Senate action sent to the House.
  8. Apr 5, 2004Resolving differencesResolving differences · Conference papers: Senate report and manager's statement and message on House action held at the desk in Senate.
  9. Apr 2, 2004Resolving differencesResolving differences · On agreeing to the conference report Agreed to by recorded vote: 336 - 69 (Roll no. 117).House roll call 117
  10. Resolving differencesResolving differences · Motions to reconsider laid on the table Agreed to without objection.
  11. Resolving differencesResolving differences · Conference report agreed to in House: On agreeing to the conference report Agreed to by recorded vote: 336 - 69 (Roll no. 117).House roll call 117
  12. Resolving differencesResolving differences · On motion to recommit with instructions to conference committee Failed by the Yeas and Nays: 195 - 217 (Roll no. 116).House roll call 116
  13. Resolving differencesResolving differences · Mr. Andrews moved to recommit with instructions to the conference committee.
  14. Resolving differencesResolving differences · The previous question was ordered without objection.
  15. Resolving differencesResolving differences · Mr. Boehner brought up conference report H. Rept. 108-457 by previously agreed to special order.
  16. FloorFloor · The previous question on the motion to recommit with instructions to conference committee was ordered without objection.
  17. FloorFloor · DEBATE - Pursuant to the order of the House of Thursday, April 1, 2004, the House proceeded with one hour of debate on the conference report to accompany H.R. 3108.
  18. Apr 1, 2004Resolving differencesResolving differences · Conference report H. Rept. 108-457 filed.
  19. Resolving differencesResolving differences · Conference report filed: Conference report H. Rept. 108-457 filed.
  20. Resolving differencesResolving differences · Conferees agreed to file conference report.
  21. Resolving differencesResolving differences · Conference committee actions: Conferees agreed to file conference report.
  22. Mar 9, 2004Resolving differencesResolving differences · Conference held.
  23. Resolving differencesResolving differences · Conference committee actions: Conference held.
  24. Mar 4, 2004Resolving differencesResolving differences · The Speaker appointed conferees - from the Committee on Ways and Means for consideration of the House bill and the Senate amendment, and modifications committed to conference: Thomas, Portman, and Rangel.
  25. Resolving differencesResolving differences · The Speaker appointed conferees - from the Committee on Education and the Workforce for consideration of the House bill and the Senate amendment, and modifications committed to conference: Boehner, McKeon, Johnson, Sam, Tiberi, Miller, George, and Andrews.
  26. Resolving differencesResolving differences · Motion to reconsider laid on the table Agreed to without objection.
  27. Resolving differencesResolving differences · On motion that the House disagree to the Senate amendment, and agree to a conference Agreed to without objection.
  28. Resolving differencesResolving differences · Mr. Boehner asked unanimous consent that the House disagree to the Senate amendment, and agree to a conference.
  29. Feb 24, 2004FloorFloor · Message on Senate action sent to the House.
  30. Feb 12, 2004Resolving differencesResolving differences · Senate insists on its amendment, asks for a conference, appoints conferees Grassley; Gregg; McConnell; Baucus; Kennedy.
Data notes

Every action the Library of Congress lists for the bill, from introduction to signing, plus the dated committee hearings. The source lists many steps twice (the chamber’s own entry and the Library of Congress copy, or a presidential and a became-law entry with the same words); those are shown once. Amendments are listed in their own section.

Report a correction

Amendments

33 amendments offered to the bill, with the last recorded step of each.

Where each amendment ended up
  • H.Amdt. 402HouseRep. John BoehnerR-OH-8· offered Oct 8, 2003Agreed to

    An amendment in the nature of a substitute made in order and considered as adopted pursuant to the order of the House on October 7, 2003.

    Oct 8, 2003: On agreeing to the Boehner amendment (A001) Agreed to without objection.

    Agreed to
  • S.Amdt. 2264SenateSen. Don NicklesR-OK· offered Jan 27, 2004Agreed to

    To express the sense of the Senate with respect to the status of private pension plans.

    Jan 27, 2004: Amendment SA 2264 agreed to in Senate by Unanimous Consent.

    Agreed to
  • S.Amdt. 2263SenateSen. Arlen SpecterR-PA· offered Jan 27, 2004Rejected

    To provide for the restoration of certain plans terminating in 2003.

    Jan 28, 2004: Amendment SA 2263 not agreed to in Senate by Division Vote.

    Rejected
  • S.Amdt. 2262SenateSen. Arlen SpecterR-PA· offered Jan 27, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 27, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2261SenateSen. Chuck GrassleyR-IA· offered Jan 26, 2004Agreed to

    To extend transfers of excess pension assets to retiree health accounts, and for other purposes.

    Jan 27, 2004: Amendment SA 2261 as modified agreed to in Senate by Unanimous Consent. (text as modified: CR S278)

    Agreed to
  • S.Amdt. 2260SenateSen. Arlen SpecterR-PA· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2259SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2258SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2257SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2256SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2255SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2254SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2253SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2252SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2251SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2250SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2249SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2248SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2247SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2246SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2245SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2244SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2243SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2242SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2241SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2240SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2239SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2238SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2237SenateSen. Peter FitzgeraldR-IL· offered Jan 26, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 26, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2236SenateSen. Jon KylR-AZ· offered Jan 26, 2004Rejected

    To restrict an employer that elected an alternative deficit reduction contribution from applying for a funding waiver.

    Jan 28, 2004: Amendment SA 2236 not agreed to in Senate by Voice Vote.

    Rejected
  • S.Amdt. 2235SenateSen. Arlen SpecterR-PA· offered Jan 23, 2004No vote recorded

    Jan 23, 2004: Senate amendment submitted

    Offered, no vote recorded
  • S.Amdt. 2234SenateSen. Jon KylR-AZ· offered Jan 22, 2004Rejected

    To limit the liability of the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation with respect to a plan for which a reduced deficit contribution is elected.

    Jan 27, 2004: Motion to table amendment SA 2234 agreed to in Senate by Yea-Nay Vote. 67 - 25. Record Vote Number: 4. (consideration: CR S271-272)

    Rejected
  • S.Amdt. 2233SenateSen. Chuck GrassleyR-IA· offered Jan 22, 2004Agreed to

    Substitute amendment to amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 and the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 to temporarily change the determination of the interest rate used for funding and other purposes from use of the 30-yea…

    Jan 28, 2004: Amendment SA 2233 agreed to in Senate by Voice Vote.

    Agreed to
Data notes

Amendments offered to this bill in either chamber, as the Library of Congress records them: each with a status read from its last recorded step: agreed to, rejected, withdrawn, ruled out of order, fell with another amendment, or offered with no vote recorded (most Senate amendments are only ever offered). The wording of each amendment is the source’s. Amendments to amendments and amendments to other bills are not listed.

Report a correction

Official record

The bill’s full text is on Congress.gov. Data through Oct 7, 2026.