InsideGov
Supreme Court · Decisions

Maine et al. v. Thiboutot et Vir.

448 U.S. 1 · No. 79-838 · 1979 term · Burger Court

Decided Jun 25, 1980 · argued Apr 22, 1980

Civil rights · Liability, civil rights acts

Majority opinion: William Brennan

The voteMajorityDissent

6–36 in the majority, 3 in dissent

3 dissents (6–3)

Affirmed. Maine et al. lost.

What this ruling means

Affirmed: the Supreme Court upheld the decision of the Maine Supreme Court, so it stands (sometimes with changes the Court made to it).

Maine et al. was the petitioner, the side that asked the Supreme Court to review the case. “Lost” means the Court did not give that side the result it asked for.

From the Supreme Court Database. A justice who agreed with the result but not the reasoning counts in the majority.

Report a correction

Summary

The opening of the case’s Wikipedia article: what the case was about and what the Court held.

Wikipedia has no article on this case, so there is no summary.

Data notes

The text is Wikipedia’s (CC BY-SA 4.0), matched to the case by its citation, docket number or name and year, and is not checked against the opinion. The site keeps the article’s opening section, ending on its last full sentence. The one-sentence summary under the title is the Decisions list’s: Wikipedia’s own ruling sentence, or, tagged “AI-written”, one Claude wrote from this opening.

Report a correction

How the justices voted

Each justice who took part, placed by their Martin–Quinn ideology score for the 1979 term. Filled: the 6 in the majority. Hollow: the 3 in dissent. Colour is the party of the president who appointed them.

More liberalMore conservativeMedianMarshallBrennanStevensBlackmunWhiteStewartPowellBurgerRehnquist

Majority(6)

Dissent(3)

Data notes

Each justice’s vote and what they wrote are from the justice-centered file of the Supreme Court Database. “Wrote a concurrence” means the justice sided with the majority and wrote separately; a justice who dissented in part is counted on the side they took overall. A justice who wrote nothing is listed as joining their side.

Positions are each justice’s Martin–Quinn score for the case’s term, the same scores as the Ideology page: negative is more liberal, positive more conservative. A score sums up a justice’s votes across the whole term, so it says where they usually sit, not why they voted as they did here. The median line is the Court’s median justice that term.

Report a correction

The parties

Who brought the case to the Court, who answered it, and how it got there.

Petitioner
Maine et al.State (Maine)
Respondent
Thiboutot et Vir.Parent or parents
Reached the Court by
Certiorari (the Court chose to hear it)
Data notes

The names are the two sides of the case’s title. The description under each is the Supreme Court Database’s category for that party, in its own wording. The petitioner is the side that asked the Supreme Court to review the decision below. “Why it was taken” appears only when the majority opinion says lower courts disagreed or were unsure about the question; reasons that would fit any case (“to resolve the question presented”, “an important question”) are left out.

Report a correction

The law at issue

The law the Court was asked to apply, and the kind of power it used to decide.

Provision
Reconstruction Civil Rights Acts (42 U.S.C. § 1983)
Kind of law
Federal Statute
Decided by
Statutory construction
Data notes

The Supreme Court Database codes the main constitutional provision, statute or court rule each case turned on, and the basis of the decision: judicial review of a federal or state law, interpreting a statute, supervising the lower courts, and so on. A case can rest on more than one. “Overruled” counts only where the majority opinion says so.

Report a correction

Timeline

What happened at the Court and how the case got there, newest first.

  1. Jun 25, 1980DecidedDecided · Decided 6–3: affirmed. Maine et al. lost.
  2. Apr 22, 1980ArguedArgued · Oral argument before the Court.
  3. Not datedTaken upTaken up · The Supreme Court agreed to hear the case (certiorari).
  4. Not datedCourt belowCourt below · Decided by the Maine Supreme Court: reversed and remanded.
  5. Not datedBeganBegan · The case began in the Maine trial court.
Data notes

From the Supreme Court Database: the court the case began in, the court whose decision the Supreme Court reviewed and what that court did, how the case came to the Court, and the dates of argument and decision. The database does not date the steps in the lower courts. Court names are the database’s.

Report a correction

Other decisions on the same issue

119 other argued cases since 1946 on liability, civil rights acts, newest first.

  1. Chiaverini v. City of Napoleon, Ohio144 S. Ct. 1745Jun 20, 2024 · 144 S. Ct. 1745Civil rights6–36–3 band

  2. Health and Hospital Corporation of Marion County, Indiana v. Talevski599 U.S. 166Jun 8, 2023 · 599 U.S. 166Civil rights7–27–2 band
  3. Thompson v. Clark142 S. Ct. 1332Apr 4, 2022 · 142 S. Ct. 1332Civil rights6–36–3 band

  4. McDonough v. Smith139 S. Ct. 2149Jun 20, 2019 · 139 S. Ct. 2149Civil rights6–36–3 band

  5. Ziglar v. Abbasi137 S. Ct. 1843Jun 19, 2017 · 137 S. Ct. 1843Civil rights4–27–2 band

  6. Cty. of Los Angeles v. Mendez137 S. Ct. 1539May 30, 2017 · 137 S. Ct. 1539Civil rights8–0Unanimous band
  7. Ross v. Blake578 U.S. 632Jun 6, 2016 · 578 U.S. 632Civil rights8–0Unanimous band

  8. Kingsley v. Hendrickson576 U.S. 389Jun 22, 2015 · 576 U.S. 389Civil rights5–45–4 band

  9. Plumhoff v. Rickard572 U.S. 765May 27, 2014 · 572 U.S. 765Civil rights9–0Unanimous band

  10. University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Petitioner v. Naiel Nassar570 U.S. 338Jun 24, 2013 · 570 U.S. 338Civil rights5–45–4 band

  11. Maetta Vance, Petitioner v. Ball State University570 U.S. 421Jun 24, 2013 · 570 U.S. 421Civil rights5–45–4 band

  12. Carolyn M. Kloeckner, Petitioner v. Hilda L. Solis, Secretary of Labor568 U.S. 41Dec 10, 2012 · 568 U.S. 41Civil rights9–0Unanimous band

  13. Virgil D. 'Gus' Reichle, Jr., et al., Petitioners v. Steven Howards566 U.S. 658Jun 4, 2012 · 566 U.S. 658Civil rights8–0Unanimous band

  14. Steve A. Filarsky, Petitioner v. Nicholas B. Delia.566 U.S. 377Apr 17, 2012 · 566 U.S. 377Civil rights9–0Unanimous band

  15. Charles A. Rehberg, Petitioner v. James P. Paulk566 U.S. 356Apr 2, 2012 · 566 U.S. 356Civil rights9–0Unanimous band

  16. Curt Messerschmidt et al., Petitioners v. Brenda Millender, As Executor of the Estate of Augusta Millender, Deceased, et al.565 U.S. 535Feb 22, 2012 · 565 U.S. 535Civil rights6–36–3 band

  17. Harvey Leroy Sossamon, III, Petitioner v. Texas et al.563 U.S. 277Apr 20, 2011 · 563 U.S. 277Civil rights6–27–2 band

  18. Harry F. Connick, District Attorney, et al., Petitioners v. John Thompson563 U.S. 51Mar 29, 2011 · 563 U.S. 51Civil rights5–45–4 band

  19. Henry W. Skinner, Petitioner v. Lynn Switzer, District Attorney for the 31st Judicial District of Texas562 U.S. 521Mar 7, 2011 · 562 U.S. 521Civil rights6–36–3 band

  20. Michelle Oritz, Petitioner v. Paula Jordan et al.562 U.S. 180Jan 24, 2011 · 562 U.S. 180Civil rights9–0Unanimous band

  21. Los Angeles County, California, Petitioner v. Craig Arthur Humphries et al.562 U.S. 29Nov 30, 2010 · 562 U.S. 29Civil rights8–0Unanimous band

  22. Keith Haywood v. Curtis Drown, et al.556 U.S. 729May 26, 2009 · 556 U.S. 729Civil rights5–45–4 band

  23. John Van de Kamp, et al. v. Thomas Lee Goldstein555 U.S. 335Jan 26, 2009 · 555 U.S. 335Civil rights9–0Unanimous band

  24. Cordell Pearson, et al. v. Afton Callahan555 U.S. 223Jan 21, 2009 · 555 U.S. 223Civil rights9–0Unanimous band

  25. Andre Wallace v. Kristen Kato et al.549 U.S. 384Feb 20, 2007 · 549 U.S. 384Civil rights7–27–2 band

  26. Clarence E. Hill v. James R. McDonough, Interim Secretary, Florida Department of Corrections, et al.547 U.S. 573Jun 12, 2006 · 547 U.S. 573Civil rights9–0Unanimous band

  27. Domino's Pizza, Inc., et al. v. John McDonald546 U.S. 470Feb 22, 2006 · 546 U.S. 470Civil rights8–0Unanimous band

  28. City of Rancho Palos Verdes, California, et al. v. Mark J. Abrams544 U.S. 113Mar 22, 2005 · 544 U.S. 113Civil rights9–0Unanimous band

  29. David L. Nelson v. Donal Campbell, Commissioner, Alabama Department of Corrections, et al.541 U.S. 637May 24, 2004 · 541 U.S. 637Civil rights9–0Unanimous band

  30. Shakur Muhammad, aka John E. Mease v. Mark Close540 U.S. 749Feb 25, 2004 · 540 U.S. 749Civil rights9–0Unanimous band
  31. Larry Hope v. Mark Pelzer et al.536 U.S. 730Jun 27, 2002 · 536 U.S. 730Civil rights6–36–3 band

  32. Correctional Services Corporation v. John E. Malesko534 U.S. 61Nov 27, 2001 · 534 U.S. 61Civil rights5–45–4 band
  33. Carole Kolstad v. American Dental Association527 U.S. 526Jun 22, 1999 · 527 U.S. 526Civil rights5–45–4 band
  34. Togo D. West, Jr., Secretary of Veterans Affairs v. Michael Gibson527 U.S. 212Jun 14, 1999 · 527 U.S. 212Civil rights5–45–4 band
  35. Michael A. Haddle v. Jeanette G. Garrison, et al.525 U.S. 121Dec 14, 1998 · 525 U.S. 121Civil rights9–0Unanimous band
  36. Leonard Rollon Crawford-El v. Patricia Britton523 U.S. 574May 4, 1998 · 523 U.S. 574Civil rights5–45–4 band
  37. Lynne Kalina v. Rodney Fletcher522 U.S. 118Dec 10, 1997 · 522 U.S. 118Civil rights9–0Unanimous band
  38. Daryll Richardson and John Walker v. Ronnie Lee McKnight521 U.S. 399Jun 23, 1997 · 521 U.S. 399Civil rights5–45–4 band
  39. Walter McMillian v. Monroe County, Alabama520 U.S. 781Jun 2, 1997 · 520 U.S. 781Civil rights5–45–4 band
  40. Gary Edwards and Tana Wood v. Jerry B. Balisok520 U.S. 641May 19, 1997 · 520 U.S. 641Civil rights9–0Unanimous band
  41. Board of the County Commissioners of Bryan County, Oklahoma v. Jill Brown et al.520 U.S. 397Apr 28, 1997 · 520 U.S. 397Civil rights5–45–4 band
  42. Roy Heck v. James Humphrey et al.512 U.S. 477Jun 24, 1994 · 512 U.S. 477Civil rights9–0Unanimous band

  43. Kevin Albright v. Roger Oliver, etc., et al.510 U.S. 266Jan 24, 1994 · 510 U.S. 266Civil rights7–27–2 band

  44. Stephen Buckley v. Michael Fitzsimmons et al.509 U.S. 259Jun 24, 1993 · 509 U.S. 259Civil rights5–45–4 band
  45. Charlene Leatherman, et al. v. Tarrant County Narcotics Intelligence and Coordination Unit, et al.507 U.S. 163Mar 3, 1993 · 507 U.S. 163Civil rights9–0Unanimous band
  46. Jayne Bray, et al. v. Alexandria Women's Health Clinic et al.506 U.S. 263Jan 13, 1993 · 506 U.S. 263Civil rights6–36–3 band

  47. Howard Wyatt v. Bill Cole and John Robbins, II504 U.S. 158May 18, 1992 · 504 U.S. 158Civil rights6–36–3 band

  48. Myra Jo Collins v. City of Harker Heights, Texas.503 U.S. 115Feb 26, 1992 · 503 U.S. 115Civil rights9–0Unanimous band
  49. Barbara Hafer v. James C. Melo, Jr., et al.502 U.S. 21Nov 5, 1991 · 502 U.S. 21Civil rights8–0Unanimous band
  50. Cathy Burns v. Rick Reed500 U.S. 478May 30, 1991 · 500 U.S. 478Civil rights9–0Unanimous band

  51. Mark E. Dennis v. Margaret L. Higgins, Director, Nebraska Department of Motor Vehicles, et al.498 U.S. 439Feb 20, 1991 · 498 U.S. 439Civil rights7–27–2 band
  52. Ngiraingas et al. v. Sanchez et al.495 U.S. 182Apr 24, 1990 · 495 U.S. 182Civil rights6–27–2 band
  53. Marlus C. Zinermon, et al. v. Darrell E. Burch494 U.S. 113Feb 27, 1990 · 494 U.S. 113Civil rights5–45–4 band
  54. Golden State Transit Corp. v. City of Los Angeles493 U.S. 103Dec 5, 1989 · 493 U.S. 103Civil rights6–36–3 band

  55. Jett v. Dallas Independent School District491 U.S. 701Jun 22, 1989 · 491 U.S. 701Civil rights5–45–4 band
  56. Will v. Michigan Department of State Police et al.Landmark · Immunity from civil rights violations491 U.S. 58Jun 15, 1989 · 491 U.S. 58Civil rights5–45–4 band

  57. Hardin v. Straub490 U.S. 536May 22, 1989 · 490 U.S. 536Civil rights9–0Unanimous band
  58. Graham v. Connor et al.490 U.S. 386May 15, 1989 · 490 U.S. 386Civil rights9–0Unanimous band

  59. City of Canton, Ohio v. Harris et al.489 U.S. 378Feb 28, 1989 · 489 U.S. 378Civil rights6–36–3 band
  60. Owens, et al. v. Okure488 U.S. 235Jan 10, 1989 · 488 U.S. 235Civil rights9–0Unanimous band
  61. West v. Atkins487 U.S. 42Jun 20, 1988 · 487 U.S. 42Civil rights9–0Unanimous band
  62. Loeffler v. Frank, Postmaster General of the United States486 U.S. 549Jun 13, 1988 · 486 U.S. 549Civil rights5–36–3 band
  63. City of St. Louis v. James H. Praprotnik485 U.S. 112Mar 2, 1988 · 485 U.S. 112Civil rights7–18–1 band
  64. Forrester v. White484 U.S. 219Jan 12, 1988 · 484 U.S. 219Civil rights8–0Unanimous band
  65. Goodman et al. v. Lukens Steel Co. et al.482 U.S. 656Jun 19, 1987 · 482 U.S. 656Civil rights6–36–3 band
  66. Shaare Tefila Congregation et al. v. Cobb et al.481 U.S. 615May 18, 1987 · 481 U.S. 615Civil rights9–0Unanimous band

  67. Saint Francis College et al. v. Al-Khazraji, aka Allan481 U.S. 604May 18, 1987 · 481 U.S. 604Civil rights9–0Unanimous band
  68. Town of Newton et al. v. Rumery480 U.S. 386Mar 9, 1987 · 480 U.S. 386Civil rights5–45–4 band

  69. City of Springfield, Massachusetts v. Kibbe, Administratrix of the Estate of Thurston480 U.S. 257Feb 25, 1987 · 480 U.S. 257Civil rights5–45–4 band
  70. Memphis Community School District et al. v. Stachura477 U.S. 299Jun 25, 1986 · 477 U.S. 299Civil rights9–0Unanimous band
  71. Pembaur v. City of Cincinnati et al.475 U.S. 469Mar 25, 1986 · 475 U.S. 469Civil rights6–36–3 band

  72. Davidson v. Cannon et al.474 U.S. 344Jan 21, 1986 · 474 U.S. 344Civil rights6–36–3 band
  73. Daniels v. Williams474 U.S. 327Jan 21, 1986 · 474 U.S. 327Civil rights9–0Unanimous band
  74. City of Oklahoma City v. Tuttle, Individually, and As Administratrix of the Estate of Tuttle471 U.S. 808Jun 3, 1985 · 471 U.S. 808Civil rights7–18–1 band
  75. Springfield Township School District et al. v. Knoll471 U.S. 288Apr 17, 1985 · 471 U.S. 288Civil rights8–0Unanimous band
  76. Wilson et al. v. Garcia471 U.S. 261Apr 17, 1985 · 471 U.S. 261Civil rights7–18–1 band
  77. Brandon et al. v. Holt, Director of Police for the City of Memphis, et al.469 U.S. 464Jan 21, 1985 · 469 U.S. 464Civil rights8–18–1 band
  78. Davis et al. v. Scherer468 U.S. 183Jun 28, 1984 · 468 U.S. 183Civil rights5–45–4 band
  79. Burnett et al. v. Grattan et al.468 U.S. 42Jun 27, 1984 · 468 U.S. 42Civil rights9–0Unanimous band
  80. Pulliam, Magistrate for the County of Culpeper, Virginia v. Allen et al.466 U.S. 522May 14, 1984 · 466 U.S. 522Civil rights5–45–4 band
  81. McDonald v. City of West Branch, Michigan, et al.466 U.S. 284Apr 18, 1984 · 466 U.S. 284Civil rights9–0Unanimous band
  82. Migra v. Warren City School District Board of Education et al.465 U.S. 75Jan 23, 1984 · 465 U.S. 75Civil rights9–0Unanimous band
  83. United Brotherhood of Carpenters & Joiners of America, Local 610, AFL-CIO, et al. v. Scott et al.463 U.S. 825Jul 5, 1983 · 463 U.S. 825Civil rights5–45–4 band
  84. Chardon et al. v. Fumero Soto et al.462 U.S. 650Jun 20, 1983 · 462 U.S. 650Civil rights6–36–3 band
  85. Haring, Lieutenant, Arlington County Police Department, et al. v. Prosise462 U.S. 306Jun 13, 1983 · 462 U.S. 306Civil rights9–0Unanimous band
  86. Smith v. Wade461 U.S. 30Apr 20, 1983 · 461 U.S. 30Civil rights5–45–4 band
  87. Kush et al. v. Rutledge460 U.S. 719Apr 4, 1983 · 460 U.S. 719Civil rights9–0Unanimous band
  88. Briscoe et al. v. Lahue et al.460 U.S. 325Mar 7, 1983 · 460 U.S. 325Civil rights6–36–3 band

  89. General Building Contractors Association, Inc. v. Pennsylvania et al.458 U.S. 375Jun 29, 1982 · 458 U.S. 375Civil rights7–27–2 band
  90. Lugar v. Edmondson Oil Co., Inc., et al.457 U.S. 922Jun 25, 1982 · 457 U.S. 922Civil rights5–45–4 band
  91. Rendell-Baker et al. v. Kohn et al.457 U.S. 830Jun 25, 1982 · 457 U.S. 830Civil rights7–27–2 band
  92. Polk County et al. v. Dodson454 U.S. 312Dec 14, 1981 · 454 U.S. 312Civil rights8–18–1 band
  93. City of Newport et al. v. Fact Concerts, Inc., et al.453 U.S. 247Jun 26, 1981 · 453 U.S. 247Civil rights6–36–3 band
  94. Parratt et al. v. Taylor451 U.S. 527May 18, 1981 · 451 U.S. 527Civil rights8–18–1 band
  95. Allen et al. v. McCurry449 U.S. 90Dec 9, 1980 · 449 U.S. 90Civil rights6–36–3 band
  96. Dennis v. Sparks et al., dba Sidney A. Sparks, Trustee449 U.S. 24Nov 17, 1980 · 449 U.S. 24Civil rights9–0Unanimous band

  97. Supreme Court of Virginia et al. v. Consumers Union of the United States, Inc., et al.446 U.S. 719Jun 2, 1980 · 446 U.S. 719Civil rights8–0Unanimous band
  98. Gomez v. Toledo446 U.S. 635May 27, 1980 · 446 U.S. 635Civil rights9–0Unanimous band
  99. Owen v. City of Independence, Missouri, et al.445 U.S. 622Apr 16, 1980 · 445 U.S. 622Civil rights5–45–4 band

  100. Martinez et al. v. California et al.444 U.S. 277Jan 15, 1980 · 444 U.S. 277Civil rights9–0Unanimous band
  101. Baker v. McCollan443 U.S. 137Jun 26, 1979 · 443 U.S. 137Civil rights6–36–3 band
  102. Monell et al. v. Department of Social Services of the City of New York et al.Landmark · Immunity from civil rights violations436 U.S. 658Jun 6, 1978 · 436 U.S. 658Civil rights7–27–2 band

  103. Flagg Bros., Inc., et al. v. Brooks et al.436 U.S. 149May 15, 1978 · 436 U.S. 149Civil rights5–36–3 band

  104. Stump et al. v. Sparkman et virLandmark · Immunity from civil rights violations435 U.S. 349Mar 28, 1978 · 435 U.S. 349Civil rights5–36–3 band

  105. Carey et al. v. Piphus et al.435 U.S. 247Mar 21, 1978 · 435 U.S. 247Civil rights8–0Unanimous band
  106. Procunier, Corrections Director, et al. v. Navarette434 U.S. 555Feb 22, 1978 · 434 U.S. 555Civil rights7–27–2 band
  107. Paul, Chief of Police, Louisville, et al. v. Davis424 U.S. 693Mar 23, 1976 · 424 U.S. 693Civil rights5–36–3 band

  108. Imbler v. Pachtman, District Attorney424 U.S. 409Mar 2, 1976 · 424 U.S. 409Civil rights8–0Unanimous band

  109. Wood et al. v. Strickland et al.420 U.S. 308Feb 25, 1975 · 420 U.S. 308Civil rights5–45–4 band
  110. Moor et al. v. County of Alameda et al.411 U.S. 693May 14, 1973 · 411 U.S. 693Civil rights8–18–1 band
  111. District of Columbia v. Carter409 U.S. 418Jan 10, 1973 · 409 U.S. 418Civil rights9–0Unanimous band
  112. Griffin et al. v. Breckenridge et al.403 U.S. 88Jun 7, 1971 · 403 U.S. 88Civil rights9–0Unanimous band
  113. Pierson et al. v. Ray et al.Landmark · Immunity from civil rights violations386 U.S. 547Apr 11, 1967 · 386 U.S. 547Civil rights8–18–1 band
  114. United States v. Price et al.383 U.S. 787Mar 28, 1966 · 383 U.S. 787Civil rights9–0Unanimous band
  115. Monroe et al. v. Pape et al.Landmark · Immunity from civil rights violations365 U.S. 167Feb 20, 1961 · 365 U.S. 167Civil rights8–18–1 band

  116. Collins et al. v. Hardyman et al.341 U.S. 651Jun 4, 1951 · 341 U.S. 651Civil rights6–36–3 band
  117. Tenney et al. v. Brandhove341 U.S. 367May 21, 1951 · 341 U.S. 367Civil rights8–18–1 band
  118. Williams v. United States341 U.S. 97Apr 23, 1951 · 341 U.S. 97Civil rights5–45–4 band

  119. United States v. Williams et al.341 U.S. 70Apr 23, 1951 · 341 U.S. 70Civil rights5–45–4 band

Data notes

Every other orally argued case with a clear vote, from the 1946 term on, that the Supreme Court Database files under the same issue as this one. The database gives each case one issue from a list of about 270 (abortion, search and seizure of vehicles, the death penalty, and so on), whatever law it turned on.

Report a correction

Official record

Read the full opinion on Justia and the argument audio on Oyez. Case data from the Supreme Court Database, Version 2026 Release 01, through the 2025 term.