United States v. Foster Lumber Co., Inc.
429 U.S. 32 · No. 74-799 · 1976 term · Burger Court
Decided Nov 2, 1976 · argued Nov 12, 1975, reargued Oct 5, 1976
Federal taxation · Federal taxation, typically under provisions of the Internal Revenue Code
Majority opinion: Potter Stewart
The voteMajorityDissent
5–45 in the majority, 4 in dissent
4 dissents (5–4)
Reversed. United States won.
What this ruling means
Reversed: the Supreme Court overturned the decision of the U.S. Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit, and its own ruling ends the case.
United States was the petitioner, the side that asked the Supreme Court to review the case. “Won” means the Court gave that side the result it asked for.
From the Supreme Court Database. A justice who agreed with the result but not the reasoning counts in the majority.
Summary
The opening of the case’s Wikipedia article: what the case was about and what the Court held.
Wikipedia has no article on this case, so there is no summary.
Data notes
The text is Wikipedia’s (CC BY-SA 4.0), matched to the case by its citation, docket number or name and year, and is not checked against the opinion. The site keeps the article’s opening section, ending on its last full sentence. The one-sentence summary under the title is the Decisions list’s: Wikipedia’s own ruling sentence, or, tagged “AI-written”, one Claude wrote from this opening.
How the justices voted
Each justice who took part, placed by their Martin–Quinn ideology score for the 1976 term. Filled: the 5 in the majority. Hollow: the 4 in dissent. Colour is the party of the president who appointed them.
Majority(5)
Potter StewartWrote the majority opinion
John StevensWrote a concurrence
Thurgood MarshallJoined the majority
Byron WhiteJoined the majority
William RehnquistJoined the majority
Dissent(4)
Harry BlackmunWrote a dissent
William BrennanJoined a dissent
Lewis PowellJoined a dissent
Warren BurgerJoined a dissent
Data notes
Each justice’s vote and what they wrote are from the justice-centered file of the Supreme Court Database. “Wrote a concurrence” means the justice sided with the majority and wrote separately; a justice who dissented in part is counted on the side they took overall. A justice who wrote nothing is listed as joining their side.
Positions are each justice’s Martin–Quinn score for the case’s term, the same scores as the Ideology page: negative is more liberal, positive more conservative. A score sums up a justice’s votes across the whole term, so it says where they usually sit, not why they voted as they did here. The median line is the Court’s median justice that term.
The parties
Who brought the case to the Court, who answered it, and how it got there.
- Petitioner
- United StatesUnited States
- Respondent
- Foster Lumber Co., Inc.Taxpayer or executor of taxpayer's estate, federal only
- Reached the Court by
- Certiorari (the Court chose to hear it)
- Why it was taken
- Federal appeals courts had ruled differently on the question
Data notes
The names are the two sides of the case’s title. The description under each is the Supreme Court Database’s category for that party, in its own wording. The petitioner is the side that asked the Supreme Court to review the decision below. “Why it was taken” appears only when the majority opinion says lower courts disagreed or were unsure about the question; reasons that would fit any case (“to resolve the question presented”, “an important question”) are left out.
The law at issue
The law the Court was asked to apply, and the kind of power it used to decide.
- Provision
- Internal Revenue Code and pre-IRC revenue acts
- Kind of law
- Federal Statute
- Decided by
- Statutory construction
Data notes
The Supreme Court Database codes the main constitutional provision, statute or court rule each case turned on, and the basis of the decision: judicial review of a federal or state law, interpreting a statute, supervising the lower courts, and so on. A case can rest on more than one. “Overruled” counts only where the majority opinion says so.
Timeline
What happened at the Court and how the case got there, newest first.
- Nov 2, 1976DecidedDecided · Decided 5–4: reversed. United States won.
- Oct 5, 1976RearguedReargued · The Court heard the case argued a second time.
- Nov 12, 1975ArguedArgued · Oral argument before the Court.
- Not datedTaken upTaken up · The Supreme Court agreed to hear the case (certiorari). Federal appeals courts had ruled differently on the question.
- Not datedCourt belowCourt below · Decided by the U.S. Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit: affirmed.
- Not datedBeganBegan · The case began in the Missouri Western U.S. District Court.
Data notes
From the Supreme Court Database: the court the case began in, the court whose decision the Supreme Court reviewed and what that court did, how the case came to the Court, and the dates of argument and decision. The database does not date the steps in the lower courts. Court names are the database’s.
Other decisions on the same issue
209 other argued cases since 1946 on federal taxation, typically under provisions of the Internal Revenue Code, newest first.
- Moore v. United States144 S. Ct. 1680Jun 20, 2024 · 144 S. Ct. 1680Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- Connelly v. United States144 S. Ct. 1406Jun 6, 2024 · 144 S. Ct. 1406Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Polselli v. Internal Revenue Service598 U.S. 432May 18, 2023 · 598 U.S. 432Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Bittner v. United States598 U.S. 85Feb 28, 2023 · 598 U.S. 85Federal taxation5–45–4 band
- Boechler, P.C. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue142 S. Ct. 1493Apr 21, 2022 · 142 S. Ct. 1493Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Cic Services, LLC v. Internal Revenue Service141 S. Ct. 1582May 17, 2021 · 141 S. Ct. 1582Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Rodriguez v. Federal Deposit Insurance Corp.140 S. Ct. 713Feb 25, 2020 · 140 S. Ct. 713Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- BNSF Railway Company v. Loos139 S. Ct. 893Mar 4, 2019 · 139 S. Ct. 893Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- Wisconsin Central Ltd. v. United States138 S. Ct. 2067Jun 21, 2018 · 138 S. Ct. 2067Federal taxation5–45–4 band
- King v. Burwell576 U.S. 473Jun 25, 2015 · 576 U.S. 473Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- United States v. Quality Stores, Inc., et al.572 U.S. 141Mar 25, 2014 · 572 U.S. 141Federal taxation8–0Unanimous band
- United States v. Woods571 U.S. 31Dec 3, 2013 · 571 U.S. 31Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- PPL Corporation and Subsidiaries, Petitioners v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue569 U.S. 329May 20, 2013 · 569 U.S. 329Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- United States, Petitioner v. Home Concrete & Supply, LLC, et al.566 U.S. 478Apr 25, 2012 · 566 U.S. 478Federal taxation5–45–4 band
- United States v. Clintwood Elkhorn Mining Company et al553 U.S. 1Apr 15, 2008 · 553 U.S. 1Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Michael J. Knight, Trustee of the William L. Rudkin Testamentary Trust v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue552 U.S. 181Jan 16, 2008 · 552 U.S. 181Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- John F. Hinck, et ux. v. United States550 U.S. 501May 21, 2007 · 550 U.S. 501Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Ec Term of Years Trust v. United States550 U.S. 429Apr 30, 2007 · 550 U.S. 429Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. John W. Banks, II543 U.S. 426Jan 24, 2005 · 543 U.S. 426Federal taxation8–0Unanimous band
- The Boeing Company and Consolidated Subsidiaries v. United States537 U.S. 437Mar 4, 2003 · 537 U.S. 437Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- United States v. Fior D'Italia, Inc.536 U.S. 238Jun 17, 2002 · 536 U.S. 238Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- United States v. Sandra L. Craft535 U.S. 274Apr 17, 2002 · 535 U.S. 274Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- United Dominion Industries, Inc. v. United States532 U.S. 822Jun 4, 2001 · 532 U.S. 822Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- United States v. Terry J. Hatter, Jr., Judge, United States District Court for the Central District of California, et al.532 U.S. 557May 21, 2001 · 532 U.S. 557Federal taxation5–27–2 band
- United States v. Cleveland Indians Baseball Company532 U.S. 200Apr 17, 2001 · 532 U.S. 200Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- David A. Gitlitz, et ux., et al. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue531 U.S. 206Jan 9, 2001 · 531 U.S. 206Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- David H. Baral v. United States528 U.S. 431Feb 22, 2000 · 528 U.S. 431Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Rohn F. Drye, Jr., et al. v. United States528 U.S. 49Dec 7, 1999 · 528 U.S. 49Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Atlantic Mutual Insurance Company v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue523 U.S. 382Apr 21, 1998 · 523 U.S. 382Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- United States v. United States Shoe Corporation523 U.S. 360Mar 31, 1998 · 523 U.S. 360Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- United States v. Marian Brockamp, Administrator of the Estate of Stanley B. McGill, Deceased519 U.S. 347Feb 18, 1997 · 519 U.S. 347Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Kevin M. O'Gilvie and Stephanie L. O'Gilvie, Minors v. United States519 U.S. 79Dec 10, 1996 · 519 U.S. 79Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- United States v. International Business Machines Corporation517 U.S. 843Jun 10, 1996 · 517 U.S. 843Federal taxation6–27–2 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Robert F. Lundy516 U.S. 235Jan 17, 1996 · 516 U.S. 235Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Erich E. Schleier and Helen B. Schleier515 U.S. 323Jun 14, 1995 · 515 U.S. 323Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- United States v. Lori Rabin Williams514 U.S. 527Apr 25, 1995 · 514 U.S. 527Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- United States v. Jerry W. Carlton512 U.S. 26Jun 13, 1994 · 512 U.S. 26Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Keystone Consolidated Industries, Inc.508 U.S. 152May 24, 1993 · 508 U.S. 152Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- Newark Morning Ledger Co., As Successor to the Herald Company v. United States507 U.S. 546Apr 20, 1993 · 507 U.S. 546Federal taxation5–45–4 band
- United States v. William F. Hill, et ux.506 U.S. 546Jan 25, 1993 · 506 U.S. 546Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Sheldon B. Bufferd v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue506 U.S. 523Jan 25, 1993 · 506 U.S. 523Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- United States v. Thompson/Center Arms Company504 U.S. 505Jun 8, 1992 · 504 U.S. 505Federal taxation5–45–4 band
- United States v. Therese A. Burke, Cynthia R. Center, and Linda G. Gibbs504 U.S. 229May 26, 1992 · 504 U.S. 229Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- Holywell Corporation, et al. v. Fred Stanton Smith, etc., et al.503 U.S. 47Feb 25, 1992 · 503 U.S. 47Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- United States v. Centennial Savings Bank FSB (Resolution Trust Corporation, Receiver)499 U.S. 573Apr 17, 1991 · 499 U.S. 573Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- Cottage Savings Association v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue499 U.S. 554Apr 17, 1991 · 499 U.S. 554Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- Portland Golf Club v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue497 U.S. 154Jun 21, 1990 · 497 U.S. 154Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- United States v. Dalm494 U.S. 596Mar 20, 1990 · 494 U.S. 596Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Indianapolis Power & Light Co.493 U.S. 203Jan 9, 1990 · 493 U.S. 203Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- United States v. Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company and Affiliates493 U.S. 132Dec 11, 1989 · 493 U.S. 132Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Colonial American Life Insurance Co. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue491 U.S. 244Jun 15, 1989 · 491 U.S. 244Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Clark et ux.489 U.S. 726Mar 22, 1989 · 489 U.S. 726Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- United States v. Wells Fargo Bank et al.485 U.S. 351Mar 23, 1988 · 485 U.S. 351Federal taxation8–0Unanimous band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Jesse C. Bollinger et al.485 U.S. 340Mar 22, 1988 · 485 U.S. 340Federal taxation8–0Unanimous band
- Arkansas Best Corporation v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue485 U.S. 212Mar 7, 1988 · 485 U.S. 212Federal taxation8–0Unanimous band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Fink et al.483 U.S. 89Jun 22, 1987 · 483 U.S. 89Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- United States v. General Dynamics Corp. et al.481 U.S. 239Apr 22, 1987 · 481 U.S. 239Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Groetzinger480 U.S. 23Feb 24, 1987 · 480 U.S. 23Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- O'Connor et ux. v. United States479 U.S. 27Nov 4, 1986 · 479 U.S. 27Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- United States v. American Bar Endowment et al.477 U.S. 105Jun 23, 1986 · 477 U.S. 105Federal taxation6–18–1 band
- United States v. Hughes Properties, Inc.476 U.S. 593Jun 3, 1986 · 476 U.S. 593Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- Sorenson v. Secretary of the Treasury et al.475 U.S. 851Apr 22, 1986 · 475 U.S. 851Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- United States v. American College of Physicians475 U.S. 834Apr 22, 1986 · 475 U.S. 834Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- United States v. National Bank of Commerce472 U.S. 713Jun 26, 1985 · 472 U.S. 713Federal taxation5–45–4 band
- Tiffany Fine Arts, Inc., et al. v. United States et al.469 U.S. 310Jan 9, 1985 · 469 U.S. 310Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- United States v. Boyle, Executor of the Estate of Boyle469 U.S. 241Jan 9, 1985 · 469 U.S. 241Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Paulsen et ux. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue469 U.S. 131Jan 8, 1985 · 469 U.S. 131Federal taxation6–27–2 band
- United States v. Arthur Young & Co. et al.465 U.S. 805Mar 21, 1984 · 465 U.S. 805Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Badaracco et al. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue464 U.S. 386Jan 17, 1984 · 464 U.S. 386Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Engle et ux.464 U.S. 206Jan 10, 1984 · 464 U.S. 206Federal taxation5–45–4 band
- United States v. Ptasynski et al.462 U.S. 74Jun 6, 1983 · 462 U.S. 74Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Tufts et al.461 U.S. 300May 2, 1983 · 461 U.S. 300Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Hillsboro National Bank v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue460 U.S. 370Mar 7, 1983 · 460 U.S. 370Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- United States v. Vogel Fertilizer Co.455 U.S. 16Jan 13, 1982 · 455 U.S. 16Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- Rowan Cos., Inc. v. United States452 U.S. 247Jun 8, 1981 · 452 U.S. 247Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- St. Martin Evangelical Lutheran Church et al. v. South Dakota451 U.S. 772May 26, 1981 · 451 U.S. 772Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- United States v. Swank et al.451 U.S. 571May 18, 1981 · 451 U.S. 571Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Portland Cement Company of Utah450 U.S. 156Mar 3, 1981 · 450 U.S. 156Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- National Muffler Dealers Assn., Inc. v. United States440 U.S. 472Mar 20, 1979 · 440 U.S. 472Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- Thor Power Tool Co. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue439 U.S. 522Jan 16, 1979 · 439 U.S. 522Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Frank Lyon Co. v. United States435 U.S. 561Apr 18, 1978 · 435 U.S. 561Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- Fulman et al., Trustees v. United States434 U.S. 528Feb 22, 1978 · 434 U.S. 528Federal taxation7–18–1 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Standard Life & Accident Insurance Co.433 U.S. 148Jun 23, 1977 · 433 U.S. 148Federal taxation8–0Unanimous band
- United States v. Consumer Life Insurance Co.430 U.S. 725Apr 26, 1977 · 430 U.S. 725Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- Don E. Williams Co. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue429 U.S. 569Feb 22, 1977 · 429 U.S. 569Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- Ivan Allen Co. v. United States422 U.S. 617Jun 26, 1975 · 422 U.S. 617Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- United States et al. v. Bisceglia420 U.S. 141Feb 19, 1975 · 420 U.S. 141Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Idaho Power Co.418 U.S. 1Jun 24, 1974 · 418 U.S. 1Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- Central Tablet Manufacturing Co. v. United States417 U.S. 673Jun 19, 1974 · 417 U.S. 673Federal taxation5–45–4 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. National Alfalfa Dehydrating & Milling Co.417 U.S. 134May 28, 1974 · 417 U.S. 134Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Snow et ux. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue416 U.S. 500May 13, 1974 · 416 U.S. 500Federal taxation8–0Unanimous band
- United States v. Chicago, Burlington & Quincy Railroad Co.412 U.S. 401Jun 4, 1973 · 412 U.S. 401Federal taxation6–27–2 band
- United States v. Basye et al.410 U.S. 441Feb 27, 1973 · 410 U.S. 441Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- United States v. Byrum, Executrix408 U.S. 125Jun 26, 1972 · 408 U.S. 125Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. First Security Bank of Utah, N. A., et al.405 U.S. 394Mar 21, 1972 · 405 U.S. 394Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- United States v. Mississippi Chemical Corp. et al.405 U.S. 298Mar 6, 1972 · 405 U.S. 298Federal taxation8–0Unanimous band
- United States v. Generes et vir405 U.S. 93Feb 23, 1972 · 405 U.S. 93Federal taxation6–18–1 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Lincoln Savings & Loan Assn.403 U.S. 345Jun 14, 1971 · 403 U.S. 345Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- United States et al. v. Mitchell et al.403 U.S. 190Jun 7, 1971 · 403 U.S. 190Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Donaldson, fka Sweet v. United States et al.400 U.S. 517Jan 25, 1971 · 400 U.S. 517Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Nash et al. v. United States398 U.S. 1May 18, 1970 · 398 U.S. 1Federal taxation6–27–2 band
- United States v. Hilton Hotels Corp.397 U.S. 580Apr 20, 1970 · 397 U.S. 580Federal taxation8–0Unanimous band
- Woodward et al. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue397 U.S. 572Apr 20, 1970 · 397 U.S. 572Federal taxation8–0Unanimous band
- United States v. Davis et ux.397 U.S. 301Mar 23, 1970 · 397 U.S. 301Federal taxation5–36–3 band
- United States v. W. M. Webb, Inc., et al.397 U.S. 179Mar 3, 1970 · 397 U.S. 179Federal taxation8–0Unanimous band
- United States v. Estate of Grace et al.395 U.S. 316Jun 2, 1969 · 395 U.S. 316Federal taxation6–18–1 band
- Bingler, District Director of Internal Revenue v. Johnson et al.394 U.S. 741Apr 23, 1969 · 394 U.S. 741Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- United States v. Skelly Oil Co.394 U.S. 678Apr 21, 1969 · 394 U.S. 678Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- United States v. Donruss Co.393 U.S. 297Jan 13, 1969 · 393 U.S. 297Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Gordon et ux.391 U.S. 83May 20, 1968 · 391 U.S. 83Federal taxation8–0Unanimous band
- Northeastern Pennsylvania National Bank & Trust Co., Executor v. United States387 U.S. 213May 22, 1967 · 387 U.S. 213Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- United States v. Catto et al.384 U.S. 102Apr 26, 1966 · 384 U.S. 102Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- United States v. O'Malley et al.383 U.S. 627Mar 23, 1966 · 383 U.S. 627Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- Malat et ux. v. Riddell, District Director of Internal Revenue383 U.S. 569Mar 21, 1966 · 383 U.S. 569Federal taxation7–18–1 band
- Fribourg Navigation Co., Inc. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue383 U.S. 272Mar 7, 1966 · 383 U.S. 272Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- Waterman Steamship Corp. v. United States381 U.S. 252May 17, 1965 · 381 U.S. 252Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- United States v. Atlas Life Insurance Co.381 U.S. 233May 17, 1965 · 381 U.S. 233Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Dixon et al. v. United States381 U.S. 68May 3, 1965 · 381 U.S. 68Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- United States v. Midland-Ross Corp.381 U.S. 54May 3, 1965 · 381 U.S. 54Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Estate of Noel et al.380 U.S. 678Apr 29, 1965 · 380 U.S. 678Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Brown et al.380 U.S. 563Apr 27, 1965 · 380 U.S. 563Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- Ryan v. United States379 U.S. 61Nov 23, 1964 · 379 U.S. 61Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- United States et al. v. Powell et al.379 U.S. 48Nov 23, 1964 · 379 U.S. 48Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- Jackson et al. v. United States376 U.S. 503Mar 23, 1964 · 376 U.S. 503Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- Reisman et al., Doing Business As Trammell, Rand & Nathan, v. Caplin et al.375 U.S. 440Jan 20, 1964 · 375 U.S. 440Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- United States v. Stapf et al., Executors and Trustees375 U.S. 118Dec 2, 1963 · 375 U.S. 118Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- United States v. Zacks et ux.375 U.S. 59Nov 12, 1963 · 375 U.S. 59Federal taxation7–18–1 band
- Braunstein et al. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue374 U.S. 65Jun 10, 1963 · 374 U.S. 65Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- Whipple et ux. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue373 U.S. 193May 13, 1963 · 373 U.S. 193Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- Maximov, Trustee, v. United States373 U.S. 49Apr 29, 1963 · 373 U.S. 49Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Schlude et ux. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue372 U.S. 128Feb 18, 1963 · 372 U.S. 128Federal taxation5–45–4 band
- Enochs, District Director of Internal Revenue, v. Williams Packing & Navigation Co., Inc.370 U.S. 1May 28, 1962 · 370 U.S. 1Federal taxation8–0Unanimous band
- Hanover Bank, Executor, et al. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue369 U.S. 672May 21, 1962 · 369 U.S. 672Federal taxation7–0Unanimous band
- Turnbow et ux. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue368 U.S. 337Dec 18, 1961 · 368 U.S. 337Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- American Automobile Association v. United States367 U.S. 687Jun 19, 1961 · 367 U.S. 687Federal taxation5–45–4 band
- Jarecki, Former Collector of Internal Revenue, et al. v. G. D. Searle & Co.367 U.S. 303Jun 12, 1961 · 367 U.S. 303Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- United States v. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc.366 U.S. 380May 22, 1961 · 366 U.S. 380Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Bulova Watch Co., Inc., v. United States365 U.S. 753Apr 17, 1961 · 365 U.S. 753Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- Meyer et al. v. United States364 U.S. 410Nov 21, 1960 · 364 U.S. 410Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- Knetsch et ux. v. United States364 U.S. 361Nov 14, 1960 · 364 U.S. 361Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Gillette Motor Transport, Inc.364 U.S. 130Jun 27, 1960 · 364 U.S. 130Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- Hertz Corporation (Successor to J. Frank Connor, Inc.) v. United States364 U.S. 122Jun 27, 1960 · 364 U.S. 122Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- Massey Motors, Inc., v. United States364 U.S. 92Jun 27, 1960 · 364 U.S. 92Federal taxation5–45–4 band
- United States v. Cannelton Sewer Pipe Co.364 U.S. 76Jun 27, 1960 · 364 U.S. 76Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Cory Corporation et al. v. Sauber363 U.S. 709Jun 20, 1960 · 363 U.S. 709Federal taxation5–45–4 band
- United States v. Manufacturers National Bank of Detroit, Executor363 U.S. 194Jun 13, 1960 · 363 U.S. 194Federal taxation8–0Unanimous band
- Flora v. United States362 U.S. 145Mar 21, 1960 · 362 U.S. 145Federal taxation5–45–4 band
- United States v. Price361 U.S. 304Jan 18, 1960 · 361 U.S. 304Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Acker361 U.S. 87Nov 16, 1959 · 361 U.S. 87Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Hansen et ux.360 U.S. 446Jun 22, 1959 · 360 U.S. 446Federal taxation7–18–1 band
- Parsons et al. v. Smith, Former Collector of Internal Revenue359 U.S. 215Apr 6, 1959 · 359 U.S. 215Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Sims v. United States359 U.S. 108Mar 23, 1959 · 359 U.S. 108Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Flora v. United States357 U.S. 63Jun 16, 1958 · 357 U.S. 63Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- United States v. Bess357 U.S. 51Jun 9, 1958 · 357 U.S. 51Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Stern, Transferee357 U.S. 39Jun 9, 1958 · 357 U.S. 39Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- The Colony, Inc., v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue357 U.S. 28Jun 9, 1958 · 357 U.S. 28Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue et al. v. P. G. Lake, Inc., et al.356 U.S. 260Apr 14, 1958 · 356 U.S. 260Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Hoover Motor Express Co., Inc., v. United States356 U.S. 38Mar 17, 1958 · 356 U.S. 38Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Tank Truck Rentals, Inc., v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue356 U.S. 30Mar 17, 1958 · 356 U.S. 30Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Sullivan et al.356 U.S. 27Mar 17, 1958 · 356 U.S. 27Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Libson Shops, Inc., v. Koehler, District Director of Internal Revenue353 U.S. 382May 27, 1957 · 353 U.S. 382Federal taxation7–18–1 band
- Haynes et ux. v. United States353 U.S. 81Apr 1, 1957 · 353 U.S. 81Federal taxation6–27–2 band
- Lasky et vir v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue.352 U.S. 1027Mar 11, 1957 · 352 U.S. 1027Federal taxation7–18–1 band
- National Lead Co. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue352 U.S. 313Jan 22, 1957 · 352 U.S. 313Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- United States v. Allen-Bradley Co.352 U.S. 306Jan 22, 1957 · 352 U.S. 306Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Murdock Acceptance Corp. v. United States350 U.S. 488Mar 26, 1956 · 350 U.S. 488Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- Millinery Center Building Corp. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue350 U.S. 456Mar 26, 1956 · 350 U.S. 456Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- United States v. Leslie Salt Co.350 U.S. 383Mar 5, 1956 · 350 U.S. 383Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Southwest Exploration Co.350 U.S. 308Feb 27, 1956 · 350 U.S. 308Federal taxation7–18–1 band
- United States v. Anderson, Clayton & Co.350 U.S. 55Nov 7, 1955 · 350 U.S. 55Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- Corn Products Refining Co. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue350 U.S. 46Nov 7, 1955 · 350 U.S. 46Federal taxation8–0Unanimous band
- Lewyt Corporation v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue349 U.S. 237May 23, 1955 · 349 U.S. 237Federal taxation5–36–3 band
- United States v. Olympic Radio & Television, Inc.349 U.S. 232May 23, 1955 · 349 U.S. 232Federal taxation8–0Unanimous band
- General American Investors Co., Inc. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue348 U.S. 434Mar 28, 1955 · 348 U.S. 434Federal taxation8–0Unanimous band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Glenshaw Glass Co.348 U.S. 426Mar 28, 1955 · 348 U.S. 426Federal taxation7–18–1 band
- Marcelle v. Estate of Lupia et al.348 U.S. 956Mar 7, 1955 · 348 U.S. 956Federal taxation8–0Unanimous band
- United States v. Koppers Company, Inc.348 U.S. 254Jan 31, 1955 · 348 U.S. 254Federal taxation6–27–2 band
- United States v. Calderon348 U.S. 160Dec 6, 1954 · 348 U.S. 160Federal taxation7–18–1 band
- Watson et al. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue345 U.S. 544May 18, 1953 · 345 U.S. 544Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- Healy et al. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue345 U.S. 278Apr 6, 1953 · 345 U.S. 278Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- Alison v. United States344 U.S. 167Dec 8, 1952 · 344 U.S. 167Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- Arrowsmith et al., Executors, et al. v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueLandmark344 U.S. 6Nov 10, 1952 · 344 U.S. 6Federal taxationLandmark6–36–3 band
- United States v. Lewis340 U.S. 590Mar 26, 1951 · 340 U.S. 590Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Korell339 U.S. 619Jun 5, 1950 · 339 U.S. 619Federal taxation6–18–1 band
- Brown Shoe Co., Inc. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue339 U.S. 583May 15, 1950 · 339 U.S. 583Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- Manning, Collector of Internal Revenue, v. Seeley Tube & Box Co.338 U.S. 561Feb 6, 1950 · 338 U.S. 561Federal taxation8–0Unanimous band
- United States v. Cumberland Public Service Co.338 U.S. 451Jan 9, 1950 · 338 U.S. 451Federal taxation8–0Unanimous band
- Reo Motors, Inc. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue338 U.S. 442Jan 9, 1950 · 338 U.S. 442Federal taxation8–0Unanimous band
- Wilmette Park District v. Campbell, Collector of Internal Revenue338 U.S. 411Dec 12, 1949 · 338 U.S. 411Federal taxation7–0Unanimous band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Connelly et ux.338 U.S. 258Nov 7, 1949 · 338 U.S. 258Federal taxation7–0Unanimous band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Culbertson et ux.337 U.S. 733Jun 27, 1949 · 337 U.S. 733Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Wodehouse337 U.S. 369Jun 13, 1949 · 337 U.S. 369Federal taxation5–36–3 band
- National Carbide Corp. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue336 U.S. 422Mar 28, 1949 · 336 U.S. 422Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Phipps336 U.S. 410Mar 14, 1949 · 336 U.S. 410Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Wisconsin Electric Power Co. v. United States336 U.S. 176Feb 14, 1949 · 336 U.S. 176Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Jacobson336 U.S. 28Jan 17, 1949 · 336 U.S. 28Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- Estate of Spiegel et al. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue335 U.S. 701Jan 17, 1949 · 335 U.S. 701Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Estate of Church335 U.S. 632Jan 17, 1949 · 335 U.S. 632Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. South Texas Lumber Co.333 U.S. 496Mar 29, 1948 · 333 U.S. 496Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- Kavanagh, Collector of Internal Revenue, v. Noble332 U.S. 535Dec 22, 1947 · 332 U.S. 535Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- Jones, Collector of Internal Revenue, v. Liberty Glass Co.332 U.S. 524Dec 22, 1947 · 332 U.S. 524Federal taxation8–18–1 band
- Bartels et al., Doing Business As Crystal Ballroom, v. Birmingham, Collector of Internal Revenue, et al.332 U.S. 126Jun 23, 1947 · 332 U.S. 126Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- Bazley v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue331 U.S. 737Jun 16, 1947 · 331 U.S. 737Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- United States v. Silk, Doing Business As Albert Silk Coal Co.331 U.S. 704Jun 16, 1947 · 331 U.S. 704Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- McWILLIAMS v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue331 U.S. 694Jun 16, 1947 · 331 U.S. 694Federal taxation8–0Unanimous band
- Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Munter331 U.S. 210May 5, 1947 · 331 U.S. 210Federal taxation9–0Unanimous band
- Crane v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue331 U.S. 1Apr 14, 1947 · 331 U.S. 1Federal taxation6–36–3 band
- United States v. Ogilvie Hardware Co., Inc.330 U.S. 709Apr 7, 1947 · 330 U.S. 709Federal taxation7–27–2 band
- Rothensies, Collector of Internal Revenue, v. Electric Storage Battery Co.329 U.S. 296Dec 16, 1946 · 329 U.S. 296Federal taxation6–36–3 band
Data notes
Every other orally argued case with a clear vote, from the 1946 term on, that the Supreme Court Database files under the same issue as this one. The database gives each case one issue from a list of about 270 (abortion, search and seizure of vehicles, the death penalty, and so on), whatever law it turned on.
Official record
Read the full opinion on Justia and the argument audio on Oyez. Case data from the Supreme Court Database, Version 2026 Release 01, through the 2025 term.